We had a great conversation about her career path and job aspirations as well as her perspective on the benefits of outdoor vs. other media. Of course, like most people, extolling the virtues of the media you are 'currently' selling became the focus of the conversation, but when I asked her the following question, I got an answer that I didn't expect.
"What is the single most 'point of differentiation' that makes your new job more enjoyable than your old one? I posed. To paraphrase her answer, she stated that "Not having to battle with Program Directors on a daily basis about what they will and won't put on the air".
For a person of this stature to identify this element of her job as the one that concerns her most shouldn't really be a surprise. There is an eternal battle that plagues not just the media business, but business in general...and it's become pandemic. The age old battle between those who make the product and those who sell it continues to curse businesses everywhere. If you throw the accountants into this toxic mess, you have situations that have to potential to slowly and tacitly destroy your business.
You all know how it goes. You, (a salesman) go out and find a great piece of new business and bring in the order. It gets booked to run on your station, you celebrate your success and take satisfaction that you are 'that much' closer to hitting an outrageous target that has been set for you. The day before it's supposed to begin airing, you get a call from the Creative Director telling you that the PD doesn't want the spots to run on his station. "WHAT?" you exclaim, then run into the studio to listen to the offending spots...and they stink. Your first response is to confront the PD with the rationalization that "it's a LOT of money" and we really need the money or we won't make our quarter. In your mind you know that the spots suck, and that you are bound to get complaints not only from the announce staff but likely from listeners as well. If you are LUCKY, you will get listener complaints. Most of them just vote with their button pushing fingers...however, despite the fact that you intuitively know that the PD is right, the billings actually become more important to you than your product. The battle ensues, and no matter what kind of relationship you have with your PD, each and every battle leaves some kind of scar on one or both of you. If you win, in the eyes of the product people, you are a greedy, selfish, lazy sales person who only cares about money. The spots air, you cringe every time you hear them knowing that radios are tuning out right across your broadcast pattern and the knife digs just a little deeper into the PD's wound...but you DID get to keep the billings. If you lose, you sulk for a while and then in your weekly sales meeting, you let everyone know what an idiot the PD is for not recognizing the value of that particular contract to the top line of the station. Either way, two people in the organization build resentment for each other and (probably unconsciously) disseminate their harsh feelings among their co-workers which ultimately causes more conflict down the line.
And so it goes with groups inside organizations that have conflicting objectives...and as I mentioned earlier, throw the accountant into the equation and the conflict intensify's as they attempt to find additional ways to keep their EBITDA margins intact. Usually at the expense of the product.
Examples of this phenomenon are all around us. At General Motors years ago, the financial analysts, despite vehement protestations from the product people (and in good conscience), found a way to save billions of dollars by building all the GM products on one platform. The problem was, in order to comply, the designers were faced with physical restrictions that would only permit them to build ugly cars that didn't work very well... the sales people couldn't sell them and the company lost tens of billions and had to beg for bailout money from the US and Canadian governments. It wasn't until a guy named Bob Lutz was appointed Vice Chairman of the company and handed the design control back to the product people that GM started building attractive and reliable cars again. The result of this move led to products like the Malibu and Volt that customers love and have snapped up in droves.
Lot's has been written lately about the late Steve Jobs who was so obsessed with design, that he had to control all elements of his Apple products, both hardware and software. Many times over the years he was confronted by both financial and sales people with demands to change his products to make them either cheaper or open-platformed to appeal to a broader market. At all intersections, and sometimes in the face of very sound and compelling logic, he held true to his belief that superior design along with products that performed better than the competition would sustain his company long after the others had failed. The end result is that Apple is now the most valuable company in the world, despite the fact that an iMac costs considerably more than virtually any consumer PC.
I am a sales person, so I know how much it might hurt for other sales people to accept that the product people should have complete control over the product, but it's not as bad as you may think.
Back in the glory days of CFOX in the early 90's I worked with a PD who really got it. He genuinely respected the value and mission of the sales department and the sales people themselves. He was also extremely passionate about his product and what he would allow on the air...but the difference between this guy and most of the other PD's I have worked with, is that when confronted with a situation like the one above, he would always have a counter-proposal or a creative idea about how we could keep the business and also have it conform to his programming taste authority. (For context, I once had a PD who told me the most important thing he had learned about programming was how to say NO to the sales department) Recognizing the value of revenue to the company, he would often sit with sales people and ask penetrating questions about client objectives and explain how bad commercial content not only hurt the station, but damaged the customer as well, and on many occasions, when we took his ideas back to the customers, they not only implemented his suggestions, but thanked us afterwards for caring enough to say something. Another thing happened that became an unexpected consequence of his actions. Sales people started to respect the product more. Bad ideas and bad creative would get stopped at the door. Sales people started to understand the benefits of heading these conflicts off at the source and confronted their advertisers, challenging them to understand how tailoring campaigns to fit within the environment of the stations programming could be more effective for them. During that time we also had both the highest audience share AND highest revenue ever attained in the history of the station.
In a business where every day presents new challenges, where rates continue to erode, budgets are reduced on a regular basis and you are fighting tooth and nail with your competitors out on the street, the last thing you need to have inside your organization is a rift between two departments. Finding ways to work together to solve client problems and create solutions is not just a great way to maintain the integrity of your product, but also a great way to keep a team oriented organization, not to mention a way to make more money.
Good read Gord. As a PD I thought of myself as a solutions finder, especially when working with a Sales Manager who helped make the product as great as possible.
ReplyDelete